Saturday, January 23, 2010

Cults! An Outline Analysis of them


This is from the CARM-Christian Apologetics and Research Ministry
It's a broad outline concerning the general characteristics of a cult. There may be some things listed here that are not true of one cult, but may be operational in another. Cults are not all the same. Most in fact have diversities in doctrine and beliefs. However, there will usually be more than just a few that fits into the general definition of being a cult
.

~~~~~~~~~

"Cults are everywhere. Some are mainstream and widely accepted. Others are isolationist and hide from examination at great expense. They are growing and flourishing. Some cause great suffering while others appear very helpful and beneficial. Which ever group it is, the ultimate end is their destruction when the Lord returns to claim His own.

What is a cult?
Generally, it is a group that is unorthodox, esoteric, and has a devotion to a person, object, or a set of new ideas.
New Teaching - has a new theology and doctrine.
Only True Teaching - often considers traditional religious systems to be apostate and it alone possesses the complete truth.
Strong Leadership - often an individual or small but powerful leadership group holds control of the group’s teachings and practices.
Asset Acquirement - often requires tithing and/or property transfer to the religious system.
Isolationist - to facilitate control over the members physically, intellectually, financially, and emotionally.
Controlling - exercises control over the members. Sometimes this is through fear, threatening loss of salvation if you leave the group. Sometimes through indoctrination.
Indoctrination - possesses methods to reinforce the cult’s beliefs and standards where opposing views are ridiculed and often misrepresented.
Apocalyptic - to give the members a future focus and philosophical purpose in avoiding the apocalypse or being delivered through it.
Experience - various practices including meditation, repetition of words and/or phrases, and ‘spiritual’ enlightenment with God are used as confirmation of their truth.
Depravation - sleep and food deprivation which weakens the will of the subject.
This is uncommon, though practiced by more severe cults.
Persecution - predictions of being persecuted, often combined with claiming any opposing views demonstrated against them as a form of persecution.
Many have non-verifiable belief systems;
For example, they would teach something that cannot be verified.
A space ship behind Hale-Bop comet
Or, that God, an alien, or angel appeared to the leader and gave him a revelation.
The members are seeded angels from another world, etc.
Often, the philosophy makes sense only if you adopt the full set of values and definitions that it teaches.
With this kind of belief, truth becomes unverifiable, internalized, and easily manipulated through the philosophical systems of its inventor.
The Leader of a Cult
Often charismatic and is considered very special for varying reasons:
The leader has received special revelation from God.
The leader claims to be the incarnation of a deity, angel, or special messenger.
The leader claims to be appointed by God for a mission.
The leader claims to have special abilities.
The leader is often above reproach and is not to be denied or contradicted.
Cult ethos
Usually seeks to do good works, otherwise no one would join them.
They are usually moral and possess a good standard of ethical teaching.
Many times the Bible is used or additional "scriptures" are penned.
The Bible, when used, is always distorted with private interpretations.
Many Cults recruit Jesus as one of their own and redefine him accordingly.
Cult groups vary greatly.
From the ascetic to the promiscuous.
From esoteric knowledge to very simple teachings.
From the rich and powerful to the poor and weak.
Who is vulnerable to joining a cult?
Everyone is vulnerable.
Rich, poor, educated, non-educated, old, young, previously religious, atheistic, etc.
General Profile of cult member (some or all of the following):
Disenchanted with conventional religious establishments.
Intellectually confused over religious and/or philosophical issues.
Sometimes disenchanted with society as a whole.
Has a need for encouragement and support.
Emotionally needful.
Needs a sense of purpose.
Financially needy.
Recruitment techniques
They find a need and fill it. One of the ways they do this is called...

"Love Bombing" - Constant positive affection in word and deed.
Sometimes there is a lot of physical contact like hugging, pats on the back, and touching.
Cult group members will lend emotional support to someone in need.
Help them in various ways...whatever is needed.
The person then becomes indebted to the cult.
Compliment them, reassure them, and make them the center of attention.
Many Cults use the influence of the Bible and/or mention Jesus as being one of their own; thereby adding validity to their system.
Scripture twisting
Those that use the Bible take verses out of context.
Then mix their misinterpreted verses with their aberrant philosophy.
Gradualism
Slow altering of thinking processes and belief system through repeated teaching.
People usually accept cult doctrines one point at a time.
New beliefs are reinforced by other cult members.
Why would someone join?
The cult satisfies various needs:
Psychological - Someone could have a weak personality, easily lead.
Emotional - Someone could have recently suffered an emotional trauma.
Intellectual - Someone has questions that this group answers.
The cult gives them approval, acceptance, purpose, and a sense of belonging.
The cult is appealing for some reason. It could be . . .
Moral rigidity and purity.
Financial security.
Promises of exaltation, redemption, higher consciousness, or a host of other rewards.
How are they kept in the cult?
Dependence
People often want to stay because the cult meets their psychological, intellectual, and spiritual needs.
Isolation
Outside contacts are reduced and more and more of the life of the member is built around the cult.
It then becomes very easy to control and shape the member.
Cognitive Reconstruction (Brainwashing):
Once the person is indoctrinated, their thinking processes are reconstructed to be consistent with the cult and to be submissive to its leaders.
This facilitates control by the cult leader(s).
Substitution
The Cult and cult leaders often take the place of mother, father, priest, teacher, and healer.
Often the member takes on the characteristics of a dependent child seeking to win the approval of the leader and or group.
Indebtedness
The member becomes indebted to the group emotionally, financially, etc.
Guilt
The person is told that to leave is to betray the leader, God, the group, etc.
The person is told that to leave would mean to reject the love and help the group has given.
Threat
Threat of destruction by God for turning from the truth.
Sometimes physical threat is used, though not often.
Threat of missing the apocalypse, or being judged on judgment day, etc.
How do you get them out?
The best thing is to try not to let them get trapped in the first place.
If you are a Christian, then pray.
But, to get a person out of a cult takes:
Time, energy, and support.
Teach them the truth.
Give them a true replacement for their aberrant belief system.
Show the cult group's philosophic inconsistencies.
Study the group and learn its history seeking clues and information.
Try and get them physically away from the cult group.
Give them the support they need emotionally.
Alleviate the threat that if they leave the group they are doomed or in danger.
Generally, don't attack the leader of the group...that comes later.
Converts often feel a loyalty and respect for the founder of the group.
Confront them when needed.
Hopefully, this basic outline will give you information to see how Cults work and how to avoid them. If you have someone who is lost in a cult, you need to pray and ask the Lord to remove them and give you the insight and tools needed. It can be a long and arduous task and very often ends in failure. This is not an easy ministry."

Friday, January 22, 2010

A Reasonable Parent Would Have Sought Medical Care for Neil Begley, doctor says


By Nicole Dungca, The Oregonian
January 22, 2010, 11:14AMView full sizeRANDY RASMUSSEN/THE OREGONIANWayne Mackeson, Jeffrey Beagley's defense attorney, addresses the jury during the trial of Beagley and his wife, Marci.


The Beagley trial
Benjamin Brink /The OregonianMarci and Jeff Beagley


ARCHIVE: Previous stories about faith healing in Oregon.Jeffrey and Marci Beagley, members of the Followers of Christ church, are charged with criminally negligent homicide for allegedly failing to provide adequate medical care for their 16-year-old son, Neil, who died in June 2008 of complications from a urinary tract blockage. The trial began on Tuesday.

The main characters in the courtroom today, including the Beagleys, are:
» Judge Steven Maurer
» Prosecutor Greg Horner
» Prosecutor Steven Mygrant
» Defense attorney Wayne Mackeson represents Jeff Beagley
» Defense attorney Steve Lindsey represents Marci Beagley
» Doctor Edward Guillery, a pediatric nephrologist


11:11 a.m. Both defense lawyers had no questions for Guillery and the state had no further witnesses.

Because defense was not expecting to start calling witnesses until Monday morning, the court will adjourn for the day.

11:09 a.m. Would Neil have survived if they had sought treatment the week before he died?

“Yes,” Guillery said. Even if they had sought treatment the day before he died, that would be the case, he continued.

Horner took up that In that day before his death, with an effort to seek medical care, would he be alive?

“Absolutely,” Guillery said. Though his condition would have been worse, medical personnel in the city have been trained to deal with that situation.

“Could Neil have survived even the day of his death had he received medical care?”

“Yes,” Guillery said.


11:04 a.m. Horner asked more about what long-term care Neil would have gotten. Guillery said he would likely be stabilized in the intensive care unit before staying in the hospital for several days. They would likely seek the treatment of dialysis, and eventually a kidney transplant.

He explained dialysis, particularly peritoneal dialysis, which is often used by pediatricians, and also said a kidney transplant “would be the best thing for (Neil).”



11:01 a.m. Horner asked more about what kind of treatment Neil would have likely gotten if he had gotten medical treatment in the week before his death.

Guillery said he would get an exam, and after several steps, he would likely be referred to a local nephrologist like himself, he said. He would have also be referred to an intensive care unit.

They would have administered dialysis immediately, Guillery said. This referral to a type of dialysis matches the opinion of yesterday’s medical expert, a local pediatric urologist.


10:48 a.m. Horner asked if a reasonable parent would have sought medical care for Neil in those last two weeks.

“Certainly” in those two weeks, and the days before his death, Guillery said.

The longevity of the symptoms and his decline were factors for that opinion, he said.

The testimony followed a lengthy back and forth between Maurer and Mackeson over the defense’s objection about Guillery’s use of statements from family members taken from the police. The jury had been ordered out of the room for the discussion.

10:31 a.m. Guillery also relied on statements from family members concerning Neil’s conditions in the last few months, and days, of his death. They showed a child with a “pattern of inexorable decline” in the last week of his death, Guillery said.

Were the symptoms presented in a way that would have raised concerns about the possibility of death?

“Yes, I think a parent would have that concern,” Guillery said. “If they had been recording the diet this way and seeing these symptoms, a reasonable parent would have that concern.”

10:24 a.m. Jurors were brought back in, and Horner came back to the food journal.

"What was in that journal that caught your attention that you think is important?"

"The fact that there was one is what really caught my attention. Parents bring in food journals .. for much younger children, and they usually reflect a significant concern that something is wrong," Guillery said.

The journal suggests that "something has been going on for a while," he said.

The contents were also striking to Guillery.

"He was getting a peculiar diet that suggests to me that there was really a problem," Guillery said. Sixteen-year-olds should be eating entire bags of groceries, he said.

The vomiting without fever or diarrhea or other flu-like symptoms was quite unusual, he said.

10:15 a.m. Maurer ultimately ruled that Guillery’s opinion on what a reasonable parent would do will be allowed in questioning.

Maurer had responded to Mackeson by saying Guillery’s opinion on that issue would help show a “community standard” that is integral to the judgment of the case.

Mackeson continued to argue that the question would not be helpful, since the jury is the one who must decide what is or is not reasonable on standards that stem from a community, not necessarily an expert looking at the facts of the case who presents a “professional standard” for the parents.

Maurer and Mackeson went back and forth with several arguments, comparing the Beagley case to medical malpractice trials and a trial involving an automobile accident.

10:02 a.m. Mackeson objected to a question from Horner that concerned the actions of a reasonable parent in the Beagleys' position. The jury was led out of the courtroom because of the objection.

The question is a doctor’s comment on the state of mind of the defendant, Mackeson said. Mackeson called it a “legal question” and unhelpful for the jury.

Horner argued that the trial is about a “reasonable person’s” judgment. What Guillery would ultimately comment on, Horner said, is whether they were doing something appropriate or reasonable. Guillery, as a medical expert who deals with many parents, would be a good source for what a “reasonable parent” would do, Horner said.

9:59 a.m. Guillery referenced the food journal again, agreeing with a question from Horner that asked if the Beagleys’ attempt to feed Neil glucerna, a formula for adults who have diabetes, was “inappropriate.”

9:58 a.m. Guillery was “disturbed” by the food intake journal that recorded how much Neil ate: “Most striking to me is the diary of the food intake, which as a doctor who is also in general pediatrics, is a disturbing thing to see,” he said.

He was also struck by the reports showing comments from family members prior to the death, as well as the printouts detectives found in the room where Neil died. They concerned internet searches about peptic ulcer disease and treating heartburn.

They were a sign of an awareness of a “significant medical problem,” Guillery said.

9:51 a.m. “Are you aware of any children dying from this condition?” prosecutor Greg Horner said.

“No, I’m not,” Guillery responded, before further explaining: “I’ve never encountered a child who has died from this beyond that early newborn period.”

“Have you ever heard of any situation that you’re aware of, of any child dying from this condition that was completely untreated?” Horner asked.

Guillery said he had never seen that situation, or heard a report of that.

Horner zeroed in on Neil’s case: why did Neil die, as opposed to these other children with this condition?

“Because he received no medical care during his life,” Guillery said.


9:44 a.m. Guillery testified that he has seen many children with Neil’s condition of posterior urethral valves. He is one of four pediatric nephrologists in Oregon, he said.

“We know that when boys have this condition, it very commonly leads to an inexorable decline of their kidney function,” Guillery said.

A minority of those children are identified after birth, and he sees those children for an extended period of time, he said.

The children who have this condition diagnosed later in life have often been brought to a pediatrician because of problems with bed-wetting or urinary accidents during the day, he said.

9:42 a.m. Guillery agreed with the medical examiner’s cause of death, which was involved complications with urinary tract outlet obstruction.

“It’s entirely obvious,” Guillery said. “There can be no doubt, based on my impressions.”

9:30 a.m. Doctor Edward Guillery, a pediatric nephrologist, was the first witness to be called to the stand today. He follows yesterday’s testimony from a pediatric urologist and the medical examiner who conducted Neil Beagley’s autopsy. Both medical experts said Neil Beagley’s condition had been beyond anything they had seen before.

Guillery's specialty, nephrology, is the field of medicine that studies kidney disease."

Indiana Couple Sentenced in Baby's Death


Associated Press in NY Times/August 13, 2005

Franklin, Ind. -- An Indiana couple who chose to pray over their dying newborn daughter rather than seek medical care for her were sentenced Friday to six years in prison for reckless homicide.

But a judge suspended most of those prison terms for Dewayne and Maleta Schmidt, instead ordering the couple to serve about a year each at a work-release center.

Their daughter, Rhianna Rose Schmidt, died in August 2003, less than two days after she was born at the couple's home, from an infection typically treated with antibiotics.

The Schmidts' church, the General Assembly and Church of the Firstborn, advocates prayer and faith healing over medical intervention but does not require members to shun medical care.

''Rhianna would be alive today if not for the actions and inactions of her parents,'' Johnson County Superior Judge Cynthia Emkes said.

The Schmidts' probation includes a directive to seek medical help for their two other children should they suffer life-threatening health problems.

Rhianna was the third child of parents attending the Schmidts' church to die since 1998 after family members refused medical treatment, according to published reports. The church is in Morgantown, about 30 miles south of Indianapolis.

Children born to members of the church in Colorado and Oregon also have died after their parents refused medical treatment.

Thursday, January 21, 2010

Jury Indicts Midwife in June Death of Newborn-Nov 16/05


Judges are beginning to look more closely at prayer-healing deaths in the Church of the First Born. In reality there is no godly, moral or legal excuse for helpless babies and children dying painful, agonizing deaths who could easily have been saved by timely medical expertise. If true to form, the COFB birth mother had received no prenatal care which may have contributed to what appeared to be a premature birth.

Jury indicts midwife in June death of newborn
Associated Press/November 16, 2005

Martinsville – A grand jury has indicted a Morgantown woman on a charge of practicing midwifery without a license in connection with a newborn's death in June.

Doris White, 72, pleaded not guilty to the charge Monday and was released without bond from the Morgan County Jail after her initial hearing.

Prosecutor Steve Sonnega said White has agreed not to assist with the births of any infants while the criminal case against her is pending.

White's indictment arose from the death of Sarah Leeman, who was delivered about two months premature by White at the newborn's parent's Martinsville mobile home.

White and the child's parents are members of the General Assembly and Church of the Firstborn, where many members turn to prayer rather than medical care.

Investigators said the infant, born May 28, weighed less than 3 pounds, and received no medical care. An autopsy showed the baby died of bacterial meningitis.

Prosecutors impaneled a grand jury to look into the infant's death.

Sonnega said the grand jury interviewed more than 25 people before indicting White. Jurors also looked at the role of the parents, Louis and Patricia Leeman, but declined to charge them.

During Monday's hearing, White said she understood the charge, but did not understand why she was charged because she had "done this for 30รข€‚years and never been questioned before."

A message was left Tuesday seeking comment from White's attorney, Bill Van Der Pol.

In May, a Johnson County jury found another couple belonging to the same church guilty of reckless homicide for refusing to seek medical treatment to help their newborn daughter in 2003.

A judge sentenced both Dewayne and Maleta Schmidt to spend one year at a work release facility.

http://www.rickross.com/reference/firstborn/f...

Wednesday, January 20, 2010

Midwife Ordered to Stop Delivering Babies


Indianapolis Star/August 19, 2006
By Tim Evans
A 73-year-old Morgan County woman who served as midwife at the birth of an infant who died has been ordered by a judge to stop delivering babies.

But Doris White -- who has delivered about 100 babies, many for people affiliated with a church whose members turn to prayer rather than doctors -- told the court she couldn't promise to abide by the order.

Morgan Superior Court Judge G. Thomas Gray issued the permanent injunction Thursday prohibiting the Morgantown woman from practicing midwifery.

Gray's ruling likely ends a legal case that began after a grand jury indicted White in November 2005 on a felony charge of practicing midwifery without a license. The indictment followed an investigation into the death of Sarah Leeman.

The baby died June 4, 2005, six days after her premature birth at the Martinsville home of her parents, Louis and Patricia Leeman, who are associated with the General Assembly and Church of the Firstborn in Morgantown.

Medical experts testified there was a 98 percent chance the baby, who died from complications of an infection, would have survived if she had been seen by medical professionals and treated with an antibiotic, said Morgan County Prosecutor Steve Sonnega.

Neither White nor her attorney could be reached Friday.

Sonnega said the injunction is a fair end to the case, but added White could face contempt and possibly other charges if she violates the judge's order.

"This was a way of getting Doris' attention," he said. "We have put her and others on notice that there are laws that regulate midwifery."

While the criminal case focused on White's violation of Indiana law regulating midwives, it was framed by the larger issue of the sometimes-blurry line between the law and religious freedom. That is obvious, Sonnega said, in the stance of church members who say they respect the state's laws but answer only to God's law.

The prosecutor said he had hoped the indictment would be enough to provide the leverage to get White to stop delivering babies. But, after meeting with her and other church officials, he realized that was not the case.

"In a way, it is refreshing to have people whose faith is so pure and strong," he said. "But on the other hand, they are out of step with the laws of Indiana."

Monday, January 18, 2010

Family Says Church Allowed Woman to Die Following Childbirth


This tragedy happened in Cushing, Oklahoma. Kathy's family still grieves over her untimely, unnecessary death. They have never been able to find out exactly what happened that day in the room where Kathy died, because they weren't allowed entrance by COFB members, to be with Kathy during her birthing process.
Kathy left 5 children without a mother. However, her husband married three months after her death.

KTUL News Channel 8, Oklahoma/November 1, 2005
By Teri Bowers
Cushing -- There is a delicate balance between religion and the law. NewsChannel 8's Teri Bowers has the story of Kathy Capdeville, a life lost in that balance. She was only 26 years old when she died giving birth. Her family believes her life could have been saved. But, they claim Kathy's church let her die in the name of faith.

Kathy Capdeville's family describes her as a devoted daughter, sister and mother to her four children. She was due to have her fifth baby this past August.

"I told her, promise to call me as soon as you go into labor because I'm three hours away," says Kathy's sister Jeanne Shadaram. "And, she promised she would. And that's the last time I talked to her."

Kathy's family was nervous because she planned to have the baby at home, attended to only by church midwives. Kathy had followed her husband into the Church of the Firstborn in Cushing. They shun doctors and rely on prayer for healing.

"We worried about this ever since she married into the faith," said Kathy's father, David Griffin. "And, it happened."

Kathy's family says it was by chance they learned she'd gone into labor. They called and were told Kathy was resting after delivering a healthy baby girl. But, within hours, the news turned tragic.

"From what we've been told, at about 5:20 she had Kathryn, the baby," Shadaram says. "And she never passed the placenta. She never passed the afterbirth. And, she bled for six hours, she lay in bed bleeding before she passed away."

"There's no reason for my daughter to have died like that," adds Griffin.

Kathy's family says she had sought medical care before and had promised she would get help if anything went wrong. But, church members told them Kathy's faith was strong.

"What they say just doesn't make sense to us, that she would willingly lay down and die knowing she had five children," Shadaram says.

And they don't believe religion should protect the midwives and other members of the church who were in the house during Kathy's final hours.

"Somebody in that house should have stepped up and did the right thing, regardless of religion," says Shadaram. "If they'd called 911, an ambulance could have come, if she was alert and awake like they say she was, Kathy could have signed a refusal to go to the hospital and it would have been done."

It is not done. Cushing police investigated Kathy's death. It is now up to the Payne County District Attorney to decide if charges are warranted against anyone who was in the home.

"It's extremely difficult," says Cushing Deputy Chief Terry Brannon. "I think any time you begin to intertwine religion in terms of potential criminal negligence, you get into an area that is awfully difficult."

The law is more clear when a child's life is at stake. The Oklahoma Legislature removed religious belief as a defense in the death of a child in 1983. Kathy's family wants lawmakers to act again to more strongly regulate midwives. They they may never get answers to the questions that haunt them about her death -- was she in pain? Did she ask for help? Or did she lose consciousness and peacefully drift away?

"I have to hope she was okay and that she went easy," Shadaram says. "And, God help them if she was in pain and they witnessed that. Then they'll have that nightmare just like I do."

Now, Kathy's family believes the only way they'll find any peace is to make others aware.

"I just miss her so much," says Shadaram. "But I know I have to tell people. This is my outlet, this is how I deal with what's happened, I do research and try to change what's going on."

Kathy's family hopes they can bring change to spare others their grief and their loss.

We tried to contact members of the church, including Kathy's husband, both in person and by phone. They declined to comment. Kathy Capdeville did not have a living will or anything similar in writing clearly expressing her religious wishes. So, her family says it comes down to their word against the church members whether she would have wanted medical attention.

There is no word yet on when the Payne County district attorney will decide for or against charges. There was another death from the very same church in 1987, when a three-month-old girl died of pneumonia. Her parents served a two-year sentence for failing to seek medical help."

Saturday, January 16, 2010

The Battle Over Faith Healing


In the Lord's hands

"Just before Christmas 1996, 1-year-old Patrick Foster caught a bad cold. As the sniffling persisted week after week, Daniel and Anne Marie Foster did what they had always done when one of their three children got sick, they prayed the devil would be driven away.

But Patrick was not healed. As winter turned to spring, he became more lethargic and gaunt. It was March when Daniel and Anne Marie noticed the growth bulging from their son's left side.

As the growth swelled, the Fosters increased their prayers. Four times each week they attended services at Faith Tabernacle Congregation Church in north Philadelphia, asking their pastor to pray aloud for Patrick.

Regardless of how sick Patrick got, there would be no visit to a doctor. And no medical treatment, not even an aspirin. Members of Faith Tabernacle, like thousands of faith-healing Christians across the United States, trust that God, inspired by the prayers of true believers, will heal sickness and disease. To seek a doctor's care would be to turn their backs not only on their faith, but on God himself. Patrick was in the Lord's hands, Anne Marie Foster would tell police.

But one day in early May, the Fosters' private religious beliefs came crashing through the doors of the Philadelphia prosecutor's office.

A neighbor had seen the listless boy sitting on his father's lap on the front steps. Patrick's body was so wracked by the growth that had ballooned from his kidney and attached itself to his liver and heart, that he needed his father's help just to lift his head.

The neighbor called the child abuse hot line.

Twenty-four hours from death

Social worker Michael Bonetti first looked in on Patrick only hours after the neighbor's phone call. The Fosters reluctantly let Bonetti inside their well-kept two-story brownstone.

Daniel Foster carried Patrick downstairs and laid him face down on the sofa. The boy winced, then groaned.

The growth, which at 6 pounds was now almost a third of Patrick's weight, was hidden by the rust-colored blanket pulled up over his shoulders. A pinkish rash covered the boy's cheeks and hands. His left eye was swollen shut; his lips were cracked and white from dehydration.

Bonetti urged the Fosters to rush Patrick to a hospital. They refused. The following afternoon Bonetti returned with the police and a court order demanding that the Fosters release Patrick to a doctor's care.

At St. Christopher's Hospital, doctors said Patrick likely would have died in another 24 hours. The large mass growing from his abdomen was a Wilm's tumor, a common form of childhood cancer that 90 percent of patients survive if they receive prompt treatment.

Doctors removed the tumor but doubted Patrick would live. He spent six months in the hospital, his parents and extended family always at his side. The prayers were never-ending.

But the battle over what was best for Patrick Foster was just beginning."